Kazakhstan’s Internet Shutdown Is Latest Episode In An Ominous Trend

This text is a part of TPM Cafe, TPM’s house for opinion and information evaluation. It was initially revealed at The Conversation.

The Kazakhstan authorities shut off the web nationwide on Jan. 5, 2022, in response to widespread civil unrest within the nation. The unrest began on Jan. 2, after the federal government lifted the value cap on liquid pure gasoline, which Kazakhs use to gas their vehicles. The Kazakhstan city of Zhanaozen, an oil and gasoline hub, erupted with a protest towards sharply rising gas costs.

Instantly, there have been studies of web darkish zones. Because the demonstrations grew, so did the web service disruptions. Mass web shutdowns and cellular blocking have been reported on Jan. 4, with solely intermittent connectivity. By Jan. 5, roughly 95% of web customers have been reportedly blocked.

The outage was decried as a human rights violation meant to suppress political dissent. The deployment of a “kill swap” to briefly shut down the web on a nationwide scale renewed questions of how one can curb the worldwide risk of digital authoritarianism.


As a researcher who studies national security, cybersurveillance and civil rights, I’ve noticed how info know-how has been more and more weaponized towards civilian populations, together with by slicing off the important service of web entry. It’s a part of an ominous pattern of governments taking management of web entry and content material to claim authoritarian management over what residents see and listen to.

A rising drawback

Governments utilizing a kill swap to dam web entry on a provincial or nationwide scale is rising. In latest years, it has occurred as a type of social management and in response to citizen protests in a number of international locations, together with Burkina Faso, Cuba, Iran, Sudan, Egypt, China and Uganda. The variety of web shutdowns is on the rise, from 56 occasions in 2016 to over 80 occasions in 2017 and not less than 155 blackouts documented in 29 countries in 2020.

Get TPM in your inbox, twice weekly.

Your subscription couldn’t be saved. Please strive once more.


Your subscription has been profitable.

The correlation between the rising use of the kill swap and rising threats to democracy globally isn’t a coincidence. The influence of this pattern on freedom and self-determination is vital to know as authoritarian governments turn into extra refined at controlling info flows, together with spreading disinformation and misinformation.

Authorized shutdown

Kazakhstan’s web is basically state-run through Kazakhtelecom, previously a state monopoly. International funding and exterior possession of telecommunication firms in Kazakhstan are limited. The Kazakh authorities has the legal power to impose web censorship and control by way of each content material restrictions and shutdowns; for instance, in response to riots or terrorism.

Underneath Kazakh legislation, the federal government is empowered to “temporarily suspend the operation of networks and (or) communication facilities” when the federal government deems web communication to be “damaging” to the pursuits of an “particular person, society and the state.”


Citing terrorist threats, Kazakhstan President Kassym-Jomart Tokayev paralyzed cellular and wi-fi providers for nearly every week and invited Russian troops into the nation to assist with “stabilization” within the wake of the protests.

The off swap

Kazakh authorities first tried to block access through Deep Packet Inspection (DPI) tools to dam web communications, in line with a report in Forbes’ Russian version. DPI examines the content material of knowledge packets despatched by way of the web. Whereas it’s helpful for monitoring networks and filtering out malware, DPI instruments have additionally been utilized by international locations like China and Iran to censor webpages or block them fully.

DPI know-how isn’t an impermeable barrier, although, and could be circumvented by encrypting traffic or using virtual private networks (VPNs), that are encrypted information connections that enable customers to defend their communications. When the DPI programs have been insufficient for a national block, the authorities resorted to manually shutting off entry, although exactly how is unclear.

One chance is that authorities rerouted DNS traffic, which is how domains lead folks to the best web sites, or labored in collaboration with web operators to dam transmissions. One other chance is that the Nationwide Safety Committee of the Republic of Kazakhstan has the capacity by itself to block access.

Digital life interrupted

The results of the web shutdown have been instantly felt by the inhabitants. Political speech and communication with the surface world have been restricted, and the flexibility of protesters and demonstrators to assemble was constrained.

The web shutdown additionally hampered every day life for Kazakhs. The nation is very integrated into the digital economy, from grocery purchases to high school registrations, and the web outage blocked entry to important providers.

In the previous, Kazakhstan’s authorities has used localized internet shutdowns to focus on remoted protests, or blocked particular web sites to regulate info and restrict the cohesiveness of protesters. In the early days of the January 2022 protest, some in Kazakhstan tried to bypass web restrictions through the use of VPNs. However VPNs have been unavailable when the federal government disabled internet access entirely in areas.

Concentrated energy, central management

The facility of the Kazakhstan authorities to institute such a widespread shutdown could also be proof of larger management of the centralized ISP than different nations, or presumably an advance to more sophisticated forms of telecommunication control. Both manner, the shutdown of total networks for a near-total nationwide web blackout is a continuation of authoritarian management over info and media.

Shutting off entry to the web for a whole inhabitants is a sort of digital totalitarianism. When the web was turned off, the Kazakhstan authorities was in a position to silence speech and turn into the only real supply of broadcast information in a turbulent time. Centralized state management over such a broad community allows enormously expanded surveillance and management of data, a robust instrument to regulate the populace.

As folks have turn into savvier web customers, as Kazakhstan demonstrates, governments have additionally turn into extra skilled at controlling web entry, use and content material. The rise of digital authoritarianism signifies that web shutdowns are prone to be on the rise as properly.

Margaret Hu is a Professor of Legislation and of Worldwide Affairs at Penn State.

This text is republished from The Conversation beneath a Inventive Commons license. Learn the original article.

Show More

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *