Saying you have to play football to analyze it is stupid as hell

The San Francisco 49ers are good, actually good — that is an goal fact, or they wouldn’t be within the NFC Championship Sport. The workforce additionally wins extra video games with Jimmy Garoppolo on the helm greater than different QB on their roster in 2021, additionally merely an goal fact. Garoppolo isn’t an ideal, or perhaps a high-level quarterback, and it’s on this level the place it will get subjective, messy and inflicting all types of drama within the week main up to Championship Weekend.

This drama launched this week when ESPN’s Mina Kimes and Stephen A. Smith talked about Jimmy G and have been essential of his play, whereas acknowledging the 49ers win lots with him on the helm. This has renewed the drained argument of quarterback wins, and it’s solely gotten stupider from there.

Kimes, unquestionably one of many brightest minds in NFL media, doesn’t function within the drained platitudes we’ve heard from voices of the previous. Her analyses accommodates nuance, and thought, and if you truly listened to what she stated you’d be a better football fan. Nevertheless, many would relatively not hear. They hear “Garoppolo isn’t that good” and hearth up their Twitter fingers to scream about how she’s improper, typically laden with a heaping serving to of sexism, due to course, she’s a girl who is a football analyst and that challenges the fragility of their male ego.

Overlook that Garoppolo hasn’t thrown for over 150 yards in a sport throughout the playoffs. He hasn’t thrown a landing, both, or posted a passer ranking higher than 68.0 in opposition to the Cowboys or Packers. Jimmy G’s defenders need to dive into the “intangibles,” as a result of that’s what you lean on when there aren’t any tangibles to converse of. Hell, let’s overlook for a second that not even the San Francisco 49ers actually believed in Jimmy G, or else they wouldn’t have invested vital capital to commerce up for Trey Lance, who they chose No. 3 total within the 2021 NFL Draft.


We’re left with Garoppolo as a quarterback who wins video games. A participant who has nice chemistry together with his teammates. A man who can lead. That’s all essential, hell, it’s how guys like Brad Johnson and Trent Dilfer have Tremendous Bowl rings. You don’t want to be an elite QB to win a Tremendous Bowl if you have an elite workforce round you. Typically a steadying drive at QB who doesn’t actually make performs, but in addition doesn’t drive them and create errors is what you want. There is such a factor as a workforce successful regardless of a QB, not due to them — and we’ve seen it time and time once more.

Nevertheless, what’s occurred right here has turned private. Kimes having the audacity to recommend Garoppolo is in the identical vein as different previous QBs who’re leaders, however not nice gamers, has reached a surreal fever pitch with former 49ers quarterback Jeff Garcia (and others) attacking her on social media for giving her evaluation of a QB’s potential.

Screen Shot 2022 01 27 at 1.29.47 PM

Garcia, whose NFL profession can finest be remembered as “Steve Younger if you ordered him from” LOVES to put himself within the dialog, as a result of he’s one of the vital forgettable NFL gamers of all-time. He did it before by slamming how Cam Newton dressed, now he’s again at it — attempting to discover some individuals who love him. And as a lot as I didn’t need to amplify his stupidity, there is one thing in right here we actually want to contact on: This logical fallacy that as a result of somebody didn’t play football means they will’t analyze football.


Have a look at Garcia’s core argument right here: None of it is primarily based in information. It’s all about how it feels to play within the NFL, what it appears like to take a snap or throw a landing. How mentally powerful it is to take the sector. All of this is completely correct, 99.9 p.c of us won’t ever know what it’s like to play within the NFL, however to lengthen that into “you can’t have an opinion on it” is laughable. Final I checked Mina Kimes has performed in as many Tremendous Bowl as Garcia ever did, so I suppose by Garcia’s logic he’s not able to having an opinion about successful “the massive one” both? Proper.

No, after all not, as a result of pondering you have to do one thing so as to have an opinion or analyze it is laughably dumb. It’s even stupider contemplating that one of the vital essential folks to the 49ers proper now is offensive coordinator Mike McDaniel, a person who by no means performed football and graduated with a historical past diploma from Yale. Inside THE OWN DAMN ORGANIZATION is a dwelling, respiration instance of how somebody can have a superb football thoughts with out ever taking a snap themselves.

If you need sensible evaluation then you want to have somebody with a ardour for evaluation — interval. Somebody keen to watch the tape, spend hours breaking it down, diving deep into superior metrics that make your head harm, then meshing it all collectively to supply an knowledgeable opinion on what they’re seeing. When you put all this work in you get somebody like Kimes, and you completely have the appropriate to disagree with that ultimate evaluation, however it ought to have a stronger counter than “you didn’t play although.” The flip facet is somebody who performed, devoted their life to specializing one place, and know the way it feels to play — however then jumps on the TV and presents evaluation with out substance. It’s everywhere in the airwaves too, and you can spot which individuals on this trade put within the work, and who doesn’t.

There’s immense worth to getting an ex-player perspective, however frankly, they’re typically utterly misused on TV. I’d love to hear in regards to the emotion of the sport, hear anecdotes about what it’s like to play within the league, hell, even assist clarify how they’ve seen intangibles play out within the NFL to converse to the facility of management, chemistry and workforce bonding. As an alternative networks ask gamers to analyze football, and whereas anybody can take a cursory look at a sport and supply an opinion, it gained’t present a lot to a viewer greater than a superficial look. One thing aimed to solely echo or counter their biases, with out an finish aim of constructing folks smarter as a end result.


Kimes is a breath of contemporary air as a result of she makes folks smarter who’re keen to truly hear to her and perceive what she’s saying when it comes to viewing the sport of football. Or, you can simply ignore it and keep dumb as a result of she by no means took a snap. That’s your name ultimately.

Show More

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *